Side-by-side or overlay PDF diff driven by one engine that reads each file into a structured model — text, vector geometry, images, form fields, annotations — and compares the models. Moves show as moves, edits show only where they happened, and any PDF type works without picking a mode.
Open a STEP / STP part and it measures itself — volume, thinnest wall, draft and undercut checks on load, plus hole detection with a BOM. Measure, section, export STL. Rust + WASM B-rep kernel, runs in your browser.
Sumerian beer with bappir (Hymn to Ninkasi)kaš (Sumerian, beer)
Sumerian beer was brewed from barley malt and bappir, a barley product often called beer-bread. The Hymn to Ninkasi describes baking bappir, malting and soaking grain, cooling the mash on reed mats and fermenting it in a vat over a collector vat. These steps are a reading of a poem and of accounting tablets, not a recipe, and what bappir was is still argued.
Fully documentedAlcoholic drinks5.5 days
Recipe
No fixed amounts recordedNo recipe amounts survive. Accounting tablets record grain issued to brewers by volume, not kitchen quantities.
unknown for Sumerian beer. Sallaberger and Stol read bappir as a sourdough that brought in the yeast (Zythophile 2024), a reading others dispute. For a 13th-century BC reconstruction from Tall Bazi, Damerow suggests spontaneous fermentation, later carried on by passing foam from one batch to the next.
Total time across the recorded steps: 5.5 days
Start
Drag the bar or press Play
What changes:Dough mixed with sweet aromatics is baked into bappir in a big oven
Step 1 of 7
Bake the bappir
Time
Not documented
Temperature
Not documented
Salt
None given
Acidity
Not documented
Which microbes the steps name, step by step
Yeasts
Output: bappir.
Flavour
Not documented
Texture
Not documented
Colour
Not documented
Microbes at work in this step
Not documented for this step.
Method
Measured measured in a studySet fixed by a specification or tested recipeReported one source reports itTypical a general value, not sourced for this fermentUnconfirmed not yet checked against a source
At a glance
Sumerian beer was brewed from barley malt and bappir, a barley product often called beer-bread. The Hymn to Ninkasi describes baking bappir, malting and soaking grain, cooling the mash on reed mats and fermenting it in a vat over a collector vat. These steps are a reading of a poem and of accounting tablets, not a recipe, and what bappir was is still argued. Made in 7 steps over 5.5 days. The longest step, malt the barley, takes 4 days (Damerow P. 2012) and runs at 24 °C (Damerow P. 2012). A yeast giving a mix of alcoholic and lactic fermentation, in the Tall Bazi reconstruction (yeast was also found in vessels there); no microbes are documented for Sumerian beer itself does most of the fermenting.
Sumerian beer used bappir alongside malt, and the hymn has the beer filter from a fermenting vat into a collector vat below. Every step is a reconstruction from a poem and accounting tablets.
In the Tall Bazi reconstruction, described by Damerow, the mash was stirred for 15 minutes at about 34 degrees Celsius and fermented 36 hours at 24 degrees, and the beer stayed stable for more than two months. The malt was dried at about 60 degrees on roofs. Damerow also notes the argument that ordinary beer was weak, usually under 1 % alcohol like kvass.
The Hymn to Ninkasi survives in copies written after the decline of Sumerian culture. Scholars dispute whether it is a recipe; Zythophile (2024) argues it is not a recipe. Old Sumerian tablets from Girsu list malt, bappir, imgaga, titab and GAR tam-ma as brewing ingredients.
[s1] Civil M. 1964. A Hymn to the Beer Goddess and a Drinking Song. In: Studies Presented to A. Leo Oppenheim.book