Skip to main content
Support

Browse by category

All categories
Fermentation Atlas

Cereals and bread

Sourdoughs, batters, porridges and steamed breads soured by lactic bacteria and yeasts.

109 entries listed here, page 2 of 2.

Compare them

FermentRegionMain stepTemperatureSaltpH
Xinjiang nang (Uyghur naan) with sour dough starterChina
Yeast-leavened breads (family entry)worldwide8–16 h18–24 °C
Yèkè-yèkè (Beninese maize couscous)Southern Benin3 days6.2 → 3.6
Żur / żurek starter (zakwas)Polandup to 4.9 months10–20 °C1.5 %
Anarsa / anarase (soaked-rice jaggery sweet)India3 days
Bibingka (traditional fermented galapong)Philippines
Birote saladoMexico
Carl Griffith's 1847 Oregon Trail sourdough starterUSA4–12 h21–29 °C
Detmold three-stage rye sourdough (Detmolder Dreistufenführung)Germany15–25 h23–30 °C
Eish shamsi (Upper Egyptian sun-risen bread)Egyptat least 15 min
Enduri pithaIndia5–6 hat least 30 °C
Ftira (Maltese flattened sourdough bread)Malta and Gozo20 min
Herman (Hermann) cake starterGerman-speaking countries4 days
Htamin chin (Shan and Intha sour rice)Myanmar2–3 h
Jamin-bang (Brazilian fermented maize cake-bread)Brazil3–6 days
Joutsenon rieska (Joutseno sour rieska)Joutseno, South Karelia, Finland
Kānga pirau (Māori fermented corn)Aotearoa New Zealandup to 42 days
Khao poon (Lao fermented rice noodles)Laos
Kishk Sa'idi (Upper Egyptian kishk)Upper Egyptup to 5 days
Kue apem (Indonesian fermented rice cake)Indonesia30 min – 1 h
Kushuk (Iraqi kishk)Iraq
Kyselo (Krkonoše sourdough mushroom soup)Czech Republic30 min
Llymru (North Welsh sour oatmeal flummery)Wales3–4 days
Odisha fermented pithas (chakuli pitha, enduri pitha)Odisha, India10 min
Puto CalasiaoPhilippinesat least 3 days
Ryeso (rye-bread miso, Noma)Copenhagen, Denmarkat least 3 months
Skābputra (Latvian sour barley porridge)Latvia, mostly the west
Sour oat jellies (Scottish sowans and Russian oat kissel)Scotland and Shetland24 h – 7 days
Uwajima barley miso made without soybeansJapan — Ehime

Bold names have a full page with the animated steps. Blank cells: no sourced value yet.

Short entries

What the sources record about each of these so far.

Anarsa / anarase (soaked-rice jaggery sweet)India

Also called अनरसा, अनारसे, anarase, anarshe.

Anarsa is a fried festival sweet of rice flour and jaggery, coated with poppy seeds. The rice is soaked for about three days with the water changed daily, dried, ground and mixed with jaggery into a dough that rests for a day or two before frying. Whether it is truly fermented is unclear, and no microbial study of anarsa was found.

  1. Soak the rice, changing the water every day3 days
  2. Dry the rice on a cloth and grind it5–6 h
  3. Mix with jaggery, knead and rest the dough24 h – 2 days
  4. Shape, coat with poppy seeds and fry

Safety: No safety limits specific to anarsa were found. Discard anarsa that darkens to black or grows mould in storage.

Bibingka (traditional fermented galapong)Philippines

Also called bibingka, bibingka galapong.

Glutinous rice is soaked overnight in clay jars with palm toddy (tuba) or a starter (bubod), which starts a light fermentation, and is then stone-ground into a batter called galapong. With coconut milk and eggs the batter is baked in a banana-leaf-lined clay pan with coals above and below.

  1. Soak the rice overnight in jars with tuba or bubod
  2. Stone-grind into galapong
  3. Mix in coconut milk and eggs
  4. Bake in a leaf-lined clay pan with coals above and below
Birote saladoMexico

Also called birote salado, birote, birrote, pan de birote.

Birote salado is the salty, crusty roll of Guadalajara, shaped like a baguette and used above all for tortas ahogadas. Its dough is fermented, and one birote sourdough held in the Puratos Sourdough Library is made with eggs, lime and beer.

  1. Mix the dough and let it ferment
  2. Shape into long rolls and bake in a hot oven
Carl Griffith's 1847 Oregon Trail sourdough starterUSA

A wheat sourdough starter that the Griffith family says it has kept since 1847, when Carl Griffith's great-grandmother is said to have carried it west on the Oregon Trail. Carl gave it away to anyone who asked, and volunteers now mail it as dried flakes that the receiver revives with flour and water.

  1. Wake the dried starter with water and flour4–12 h · 21–29 °C
  2. Feed twice more to build it up
  3. Keep it fed
  4. Dry a portion to post

Safety: The keepers suggest a water temperature that feels neither warm nor cold on the wrist, and filtered water if tap water is heavily chlorinated.

Detmold three-stage rye sourdough (Detmolder Dreistufenführung)Germany

Also called Detmolder Dreistufenführung, Detmolder Dreistufensauer, Detmold method, three-stage sour.

A ripe rye sourdough is built up in three stages before it goes into the bread dough. Each stage has its own firmness, temperature and time, set to favour yeasts first, then acid and aroma, then a short warm finish. The whole sour ripens in about a day.

  1. Anfrischsauer (freshening sour)5–6 h · 25–26 °C
  2. Grundsauer (basic sour)15–25 h · 23–30 °C
  3. Vollsauer (full sour)3 h · 28–30 °C
  4. Mix the bread dough and rest it28–29 °C
  5. Shape and bake

Safety: Rye is the cereal most affected by ergot, and the BfR says rye flour, wholemeal rye bread, rye bread and rolls can carry raised ergot alkaloid levels depending on the harvest. For children aged six months to six years, it judged from German monitoring data for 2013 to 2021 that acute health effects are possible with a medium likelihood, especially from rye products. Pistor's guide values for a ripe full sour are pH 3.8–4.0, which is a quality guide and not a safety limit.

Eish shamsi (Upper Egyptian sun-risen bread)Egypt

Also called عيش شمسي, aish shamsi, al-shamsi bread, solar bread, sun bread.

Wheat flour is mixed with a leaven of yeasty dough, water and salt, and the dough is cut into rounds that rise in the sun on bran-dusted boards. The risen rounds are marked with a wooden splint and baked briefly in a hot oven into thick, round loaves.

  1. Prepare the leaven and dough
  2. Portion and rise in the sunat least 15 min
  3. Mark the tops
  4. Bake in a hot oven10 min
Enduri pithaIndia

Rice and skinned black gram are soaked, ground and left to ferment, as for idli. The batter is spread on a fresh turmeric leaf, filled with coconut and jaggery, folded and steamed. One recipe gives 5 to 6 hours for the fermenting; no study has measured it.

  1. Soak rice and black gram separately4 h
  2. Grind into a thick batter
  3. Ferment the batter5–6 h · at least 30 °C
  4. Spread on turmeric leaves, fill and fold
  5. Steam10–15 min
Ftira (Maltese flattened sourdough bread)Malta and Gozo

Also called ftira, ftajjar (plural), il-ftira Maltija, Maltese ftira.

Ftira is a ring-shaped, semi-flat Maltese sourdough bread made from flour, water and salt, the same ingredients as a normal Maltese loaf. Skilled bakers shape it by hand, pressing the air out and pinching a hole in the middle, and it bakes in about 20 minutes at double the temperature of the traditional loaf. It is eaten with fillings such as tomato, tuna, capers and olives.

  1. Make the dough
  2. Shape by hand
  3. Bake hot and fast20 min
  4. Fill the ftira
Herman (Hermann) cake starterGerman-speaking countries

Also called Hermann, Hermann-Teig, Hermannkuchen, Glückskuchen, Herman cake.

A very wet starter of flour, sugar, water and a little dry yeast is stirred daily for ten days and fed twice with flour, sugar and milk. On day 10 it is divided into portions; one is baked into a sweet cake, one is kept to start again, and the rest are given to friends with the instructions.

  1. Mix the starter
  2. Rest warm, then stir daily4 days
  3. First feed (day 5)
  4. Stir daily4 days
  5. Second feed and divide (day 10)
  6. Bake a cake

Safety: University extension advice calls raw milk unsafe and says to discard a starter that smells bad or shows orange or red spots or slime. Milk and eggs can support the growth of disease-causing bacteria, so a starter of water, flour, sugar and yeast is a safer choice than one with milk and wild yeast. After the first two or three days at room temperature, NDSU says most food safety experts advise keeping the batter refrigerated, and the US Amish recipe's ten days on the counter does not follow that. NDSU also says outbreaks have not been directly linked to modern friendship starters, but it still advises these precautions.

Htamin chin (Shan and Intha sour rice)Myanmar

Also called ထမင်းချဉ်, htamin jin, htamin gyin, sour rice.

Htamin chin, "sour rice", is a Shan dish of rice kneaded with boiled fish or meat and tomato and shaped into balls. Ishige recorded a Shan version eaten two to three hours after mixing, with the sourness coming from the tomato. It is a boundary entry; a fermented-rice version is mentioned only in secondary sources.

  1. Knead rice with boiled fish or meat and tomato
  2. Leave the mixture to stand2–3 h
  3. Shape into balls and serve

Safety: The Shan version is eaten within a few hours of mixing cooked fish or meat with rice.

Jamin-bang (Brazilian fermented maize cake-bread)Brazil

Also called jamin-bang.

FAO lists jamin-bang as a Brazilian bread made from maize that is fermented for three to six days and then cooked as a cake. No other description of the process was found.

  1. Ferment the maize3–6 days
  2. Cook as a cake
Joutsenon rieska (Joutseno sour rieska)Joutseno, South Karelia, Finland

Also called Joutsenon rieska, joutsenolainen rieska, Joutseno rieska.

Joutsenon rieska is a thick, leavened barley and wheat flatbread from Joutseno in South Karelia. In most of Finland rieska is an unleavened flatbread, but in the south-east it is a thick leavened bread of barley and wheat flour, water and buttermilk; Finnish Wikipedia calls the Joutseno bread a sour bread (hapanleipä).

  1. Mix a barley and wheat dough with buttermilk and water
  2. Leave the dough to rise
  3. Shape thick rieskas and bake

Safety: The bread is baked.

Kānga pirau (Māori fermented corn)Aotearoa New Zealand

Also called kānga pirau, kānga kōpiro, kānga wai, rotten corn, kanga kopiro, water corn.

Kānga pirau is Māori fermented corn. Whole maize cobs in woven baskets are left in a running stream for up to six weeks, until the kernels have settled to the bottom of the basket; the corn is then mashed and often eaten with cream and sugar. The ferment has a pungent aroma.

  1. Pack cobs in baskets
  2. Leave in running water to fermentup to 42 days
  3. Mash the fermented corn
  4. Serve as a mash or bake

Safety: A HACCP-based study of traditional Māori food preparation judged kānga kōpiro likely to produce a safe food because it undergoes an acid fermentation. Modern versions ferment the cobs in containers of water.

Khao poon (Lao fermented rice noodles)Laos

Also called ເຂົ້າປຸ້ນ, khao pun, khaw poon, khao poun.

Rice is soaked until it sours, ground and left to stand as wet flour, then forced through a perforated mould into boiling water as fresh noodles. It is the Lao member of the fermented rice noodle family; no study has yet measured its fermentation.

  1. Soak the rice until it sours
  2. Grind the soaked rice
  3. Let the flour stand, then press and knead
  4. Press through a mould into boiling water, then rinse cold

Safety: In Thai khanom jeen, a related noodle, noodles kept at pH around 4 or lower did not liquefy, while noodles raised to pH 6 or above were digested by starch-degrading bacteria, so fresh noodles are best kept acidic and eaten within a few days.

Kishk Sa'idi (Upper Egyptian kishk)Upper Egypt

Also called كشك صعيدي, Egyptian kishk, Seidi kishk.

Kishk sa'idi is a dried sour food of Upper Egypt made from boiled wheat and soured milk. Wheat is boiled soft, dried, ground and sieved; milk soured in earthenware is mixed in to make a paste (hamma) that ferments for about a day, is thinned with more soured milk, ferments again and is rolled into small balls and sun-dried.

  1. Sour the milk
  2. Boil, dry, grind and sieve the wheat
  3. Moisten the wheat and mix with soured milk into a paste (hamma); ferment24 h
  4. Thin with soured milk or whey and ferment again24 h
  5. Form small balls and sun-dry on rooftopsup to 5 days

Safety: In a 2022 laboratory study of wheat and quinoa kishk made with heated laban rayeb, the authors saw no spoilage or pathogenic microbes over 3 months at room temperature and credit the acidity and low water activity. Their counts covered total bacteria, lactic bacteria, coliforms, yeasts and moulds, with no test for a named pathogen. That recipe was not kishk sa'idi, and it heated the milk first.

Kue apem (Indonesian fermented rice cake)Indonesia

Also called kue apem, apem, apem panggang (baked apem).

Kue apem is a soft Indonesian cake of rice flour, coconut milk and sugar, leavened with tape (fermented cassava) and yeast. The batter is left to rise briefly, then baked in a small round apem mould.

  1. Mix the batter
  2. Leave the batter to rise30 min – 1 h
  3. Bake in small round moulds10 min

Safety: The cakes in the cited studies are baked, which cooks the batter through.

Kushuk (Iraqi kishk)Iraq

Also called كشك.

Kushuk is the Iraqi name for a dried mixture of fermented milk and wheat, the same family as kishk, tarhana and trahanas. No source found describes how it is made in Iraq, so this entry only records the name.

  1. Mix fermented milk with wheat
  2. Let it ferment
  3. Shape and dry in the sun
Kyselo (Krkonoše sourdough mushroom soup)Czech Republic

Also called kyselo, krkonošské kyselo.

Kyselo is a sour soup from the Krkonoše mountains made with bread sourdough (kvásek). The sourdough is thinned with lukewarm water and left for several hours or overnight to sour further, then simmered into a broth of mushrooms, caraway and potatoes, finished with fried onion and served with eggs.

  1. Thin the sourdough with lukewarm water and leave it to sourSeveral hours, best overnight
  2. Cook mushrooms, caraway and potatoes in salted water
  3. Add the soured sourdough and simmer; stir in fried onion30 min
  4. Serve with scrambled or poached eggs

Safety: The sour liquid is simmered in the soup. In one recipe raw eggs are stirred into the fried onion so that they stay partly raw, then stirred into the soup and boiled only briefly (Novinky). The CzechTourism recipe serves runny scrambled or poached eggs. The FDA says to cook eggs until both yolk and white are firm, and that scrambled eggs should not be runny, to prevent illness from bacteria.

Llymru (North Welsh sour oatmeal flummery)Wales

Also called llymru, sucan, uwd sucan, Welsh flummery, sucan blawd.

Llymru is a Welsh oatmeal jelly. Oatmeal is steeped in cold water with a little buttermilk for three or four days until it sours, then strained, and the sour liquid is boiled hard until it thickens and is poured into a wet dish to set.

  1. Steep oatmeal in cold water and buttermilk until sour3–4 days
  2. Strain through a very fine sieve, squeezing the meal
  3. Boil briskly, stirring with a wooden stick, until it falls in a thin tail
  4. Pour into a wet dish and leave to cool and set

Safety: The sour liquid is boiled before eating.

Odisha fermented pithas (chakuli pitha, enduri pitha)Odisha, India

Also called ଚକୁଳି ପିଠା, ଏଣ୍ଡୁରି ପିଠା, chakuli, enduri, haladi patra pitha.

Rice and dehulled black gram are soaked, ground into a batter and left to ferment. The batter is either poured thin on a hot griddle as chakuli pitha, or spread on turmeric leaves around a sweet coconut filling and steamed as enduri pitha.

  1. Soak rice and black gram separately
  2. Grind into a batter and salt it
  3. Leave the batter to ferment
  4. Spread on turmeric leaves with a sweet filling (enduri)
  5. Steam the parcels (enduri) or fry thin on a griddle (chakuli)10 min
Puto CalasiaoPhilippines

Also called puto Calasiao, Calasiao rice cakes, Calasiao puto.

Rice is soaked, ground wet and left to ferment in old earthen jars with a little sugar, then steamed in small cups into bite-size white cakes. Local accounts say only rice, water and sugar go in, and one credits the seasoned jars for the fermentation. No study has measured the process.

  1. Soak rice and grind it wet into galapong
  2. Ferment in old earthen jarsat least 3 days
  3. Steam in small cups
Ryeso (rye-bread miso, Noma)Copenhagen, Denmark

Ryeso is a miso-style paste that Noma Projects makes from leftover rye bread. The bread is blended with rice koji and salt, packed into barrels and aged for at least three months while koji enzymes break it down into a dark, savoury paste.

  1. Blend rye bread with rice koji and salt
  2. Pack into barrels
  3. Ageat least 3 months
Skābputra (Latvian sour barley porridge)Latvia, mostly the west

Also called skābputra, sour porridge.

Barley groats are cooked in water, curdled milk is stirred in, and the porridge is kept warm until it turns sour. It is served with sour cream or butter, or as a side dish.

  1. Cook the barley in water without salt
  2. Stir in half the curdled milk, then cool
  3. Add the rest of the curdled milk and keep warm until sour

Safety: The recipe leaves the cooked porridge in a warm place until it sours. The CDC says bacteria multiply rapidly between 40 °F and 140 °F (4 °C and 60 °C), and that perishable food should not be left out for more than 2 hours.

Sour oat jellies (Scottish sowans and Russian oat kissel)Scotland and Shetland

Also called sowans, sowens, súghan, virpa (Shetland), овсяный кисель, swats (the sour liquor).

Oat husks with starch still on them, or oat flakes, are steeped in water until they sour. The liquor is strained off and left to settle; the starch that sinks is boiled with water and salt into a sour porridge or jelly, and the thin sour liquid on top (swats) is drunk.

  1. Steep the oats until sour24 h – 7 days
  2. Strain
  3. Let the liquor settle (sowans)
  4. Boil with water and salt5 min

Safety: The starch is boiled before it is eaten; the raw sour liquid (swats) is drunk uncooked.

Uwajima barley miso made without soybeansJapan — Ehime

Also called 宇和島麦みそ.

Uwajima barley miso is a paste made only from naked-barley koji and salt, with no soybeans. Ehime naked barley, of which the prefecture is Japan's largest producer, is made into koji and aged with salt by Ii Shōten of Uwajima using a method handed down from its ancestors. Because Japan's food labelling definition of miso requires soybeans, it cannot be called miso in the ingredient list.

  1. Make naked barley into koji
  2. Mix the koji with salt and age it (no soybean)

Safety: The recipe has no soybean, which matters for soy allergy, but no source we read tests the paste for traces of soy. It is made from barley, and barley contains gluten, so it is not suitable for people with celiac disease.

Numbers come from cited sources and carry a label that says how each is known. How this atlas is made