Skip to main content
Support

Browse by category

All categories
Fermentation Atlas

Vinegar

Vinegars, where acetic acid bacteria turn alcohol into acetic acid.

35 entries listed here.

Compare them

FermentRegionMain stepTemperatureSaltpH
'Bitter wine' (苦酒) vinegars: bean, wheat, water, quick, honey and 'foreign' vinegarsNorthern China14 days
Aceto Balsamico Tradizionale (di Modena / di Reggio Emilia)Provinces of Modena and Reggio Emilia, Emilia-Romagna, Italyat least 12 years
Aceto di miele (honey vinegar)Italy42–56 days21–27 °C
Baoning (Sichuan bran) vinegarLangzhong30 days30–35 °C
Barley vinegar (大麥酢法)Northern China3–4 days
Day-named and sajeolcho vinegars (병정초 丙丁醋, 사절초 四節醋)Korea
Divine vinegar from huangzheng and bran (神酢法) and flatbread-fed vinegar (燒餅作酢法)Northern China30 days
Glutinous-millet divine vinegar (秫米神酢法) and its two variantsNorthern China30 days
Glutinous-millet vinegar on sour starch water (秫米酢法)Northern China30 days
Great vinegar (作大酢法)Northern China21 days
Joseon grain and honey vinegarsKorea40 days
Komezu (rice vinegar) and akazu (red sake-lees vinegar)Japanat least 3 years
Kurozu (Kagoshima pot-brewed black rice vinegar)Fukuyama-cho and Hayato-cho, Kirishima City, Kagoshima, Japanat least 6 months
Lees-and-bran percolation vinegar and other lees vinegars (糟糠酢, 酒糟酢, 糟酢)Northern China7–14 days
Makgeolli vinegar (makgeolli-sikcho) and Korean rice vinegarsKorea17–20 days30 °C4.3–4.4 → 3.2
Millet-and-qu vinegar (粟米麴作酢法)Northern China21 days
Orléans method (slow surface vinegar)Orléans, France21 days – 12 months27–29 °C
Palm / toddy vinegar (incl. Myanmar htan-ye vinegar)Myanmar6 months3.9 → 3.09
Persimmon vinegar (Korean gamsikcho, Japanese kakisu)South Korea, Japan21 days – 25 years15 °C3–3.7
Quick or generator (trickle) process vinegarGermany, from the 1820sup to 7 days
Shanxi aged vinegar (Shanxi laochencu)Shanxi, Chinaat least 12 months
Submerged fermentation vinegar (acetator)Worldwide industrial practice, from the 20th century21–24 h30–31 °C
Sukang Iloko (Ilocos sugarcane vinegar)Ilocos and La Union, northern Luzon, Philippines2.6–3.9
Vinagre de Jerez (sherry vinegar)Jerez area, Cádiz and Seville provinces, Andalusia, Spainat least 6 months1.9–2.4
Vinegars from failed wine (迴酒酢, 動酒酢)Northern China7 days
Yongchun aged vinegar and Fujian red-qu (Hongqu) vinegarYongchun County, Quanzhou, Fujian, China3–10 years3.5
Zhenjiang (Chinkiang) aromatic vinegarZhenjiang, Jiangsu, China3 months – 8 years
Aceto di pere (pear vinegar)Italy
Changpo-cho (창포초, 菖蒲醋), sweet-flag vinegarKorea
Joseon fruit, flower and root vinegarsKorea
Kaong palm vinegar (sukang kaong, sukang irok)Philippines2 months – 3 years
Mugukcho (무국초, 無麴醋), vinegar without nurukKorea7 days
Other vinegars (catalogue)
Samhwang-cho (삼황초, 三黃醋), dog-days old-rice vinegarKorea
Vinagre criollo (Ecuadorian banana vinegar)Coastal4–5 days

Bold names have a full page with the animated steps. Blank cells: no sourced value yet.

Short entries

What the sources record about each of these so far.

Aceto di pere (pear vinegar)Italy

Also called aceto di pere, pear vinegar.

Pear vinegar is made by crushing and pressing high-sugar pears, letting the juice ferment, and leaving it under a surface film of acetic bacteria, the vinegar mother, until the alcohol turns to acetic acid. A special further process turns it into a dense, dark, sweet-sour condiment. No source read gives times, temperatures or acidity for it.

  1. Crush and press pears
  2. Rest for alcoholic fermentation
  3. Acetify under a surface mother
  4. Optional: special processing into a dense, dark sweet-sour condiment
Changpo-cho (창포초, 菖蒲醋), sweet-flag vinegarKorea

Also called 창포초, 菖蒲醋, calamus vinegar.

A Joseon vinegar flavoured with sweet flag (Acorus calamus), recorded in household books from the 16th century on. The Suun japbang (about 1540) lists it among its vinegars, and the Sallim gyeongje (1715) records it as a vegetable vinegar. No method with steps could be read this round.

Safety: Sweet flag, Acorus calamus, is a flavouring in this vinegar. The US treats food with added calamus, its oil or extract as adulterated, and its rule names β-asarone as the compound to test for. The sources give no dose, so do not copy it at home.

Joseon fruit, flower and root vinegarsKorea

Also called 대추초 棗醋, 전자손초 傳子孫酢, 매자초 梅子醋, 도초 桃酢, 감초/시초 枾醋, 목통초 木通醋.

Joseon household books record vinegars of persimmon, jujube, plum, peach, akebia, lotus and bellflower root beside the grain vinegars. The Sallim gyeongje (1715) has persimmon and jujube vinegars and vegetable vinegars of sweet flag and bellflower. The Eumsik dimibang's plum vinegar (매자초) is smoked plum soaked in strong vinegar, dried and powdered, so it is a flavoured vinegar powder rather than a ferment.

Safety: The sweet-flag vinegar uses Acorus calamus. The US treats food with added calamus, its oil or extract as adulterated, and its rule names β-asarone as the compound to test for. Do not copy it at home.

Kaong palm vinegar (sukang kaong, sukang irok)Philippines

Also called sukang kaong, sukang irok, sukang tubâ, irok palm vinegar, arenga palm vinegar, palm vinegar.

Kaong palm vinegar is made from the sap of the sugar palm (Arenga pinnata), tapped from the cut flower stalk. Wild yeasts turn the sap into palm toddy (tubâ) and acetic bacteria then turn the toddy into vinegar in earthen jars. Philippine food rules class it as a natural vinegar, which needs less acid than vinegar made from wine or alcohol.

  1. Prepare the flower stalkMonths while the flowers develop, with the stalk shaken daily (Wikipedia)
  2. Cut the stalk and collect the sap
  3. Ferment to palm toddy
  4. Acetic fermentation
  5. Modern: pasteurise and age2 months – 3 years

Safety: The minimum acidity in the 2024 Philippine draft standard is a quality rule; the draft also requires the code of hygienic practice and bars vinegar eels and heavy sediment.

Mugukcho (무국초, 無麴醋), vinegar without nurukKorea

Also called 무국초방, 無麴醋方, no-starter vinegar.

A Joseon rice vinegar from the Imwon simnyukji (19th century) made without nuruk. Rice is soaked, steamed and left in a jar until mould grows on it, then boiled water is added and it ripens into vinegar. The method is known here only from earlier notes on Lim and Cha (2010).

  1. Soak rice 3 days, steam well, put in a jar
  2. Wait for mould7 days
  3. Add boiled water and ripen

Safety: Steamed rice is left a week until mould grows, and no source we read says which moulds. WHO says moulds that can make mycotoxins grow on cereals, often in warm, damp conditions, and it lists rice among the crops aflatoxins affect. It also says most mycotoxins survive food processing. Do not copy this at home.

Other vinegars (catalogue)

A catalogue of vinegars that have no entry of their own. Each one follows the same two stages, an alcoholic fermentation of a sugary or starchy raw material and then acetic fermentation by acetic bacteria, and they differ mainly in the raw material. One quality standard defines up to ten types, from wine, fruit and cider vinegar to malt and alcohol vinegar.

Made like Orléans method (slow surface vinegar).

Samhwang-cho (삼황초, 三黃醋), dog-days old-rice vinegarKorea

Also called 삼황초, 황삼초방.

A Joseon rice vinegar made from old rice during the three dog days (삼복), the hottest days of summer. It is recorded in the Sallim gyeongje (about 1715) and the Imwon simnyukji, and is known here only from earlier notes on Lim and Cha (2010).

  1. Make during the three dog days (삼복) from old rice
Vinagre criollo (Ecuadorian banana vinegar)Coastal

Also called vinagre montubio, vinagre de guineo, vinagre criollo.

Vinagre criollo, also called vinagre montubio or vinagre de guineo, is a home banana vinegar of coastal Ecuador. Ripe bananas are peeled and shut in a covered container until they break down into a light-brown liquid, which is sieved off and keeps souring. Artisanal banana vinegar from Rocafuerte in Manabí grows a mother of vinegar that a Manabí university study used as its acetic starter.

  1. Ripen the bunchabout a week, until the fruit turns yellow
  2. Peel and seal in a covered container4–5 days
  3. Sieve into another vessel and let it keep souring

Numbers come from cited sources and carry a label that says how each is known. How this atlas is made